Last edited by Mezill
Wednesday, April 22, 2020 | History

1 edition of Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults. found in the catalog.

Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults.

Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults.

  • 313 Want to read
  • 33 Currently reading

Published by Law Reform Commission in Winnipeg, Man., Canada .
Written in English

    Places:
  • Manitoba.
    • Subjects:
    • Involuntary sterilization -- Law and legislation -- Manitoba.,
    • Informed consent (Medical law) -- Manitoba.,
    • Minors -- Manitoba.

    • Edition Notes

      Includes bibliographical references.

      ContributionsManitoba. Law Reform Commission.
      Classifications
      LC ClassificationsKEM424.5 .D57 1990
      The Physical Object
      Paginationii, 40 p. ;
      Number of Pages40
      ID Numbers
      Open LibraryOL1659526M
      LC Control Number91222186

      The Canadian Association for the Mentally Retarded hopes that the outcome of these appeals will settle the rights of the retarded. The practice of sterilizing mentally handicapped people in Canada is now new. In , Alberta’s Sterilization Act legalized involuntary sterilization upon permission of a Eugenics Board. ©— Bioethics Research Library Box Washington DC


Share this book
You might also like
Sixty eventful years

Sixty eventful years

Egyptian policy of the Unionist Government

Egyptian policy of the Unionist Government

Observations on judicial procedure in actions criminal and civil

Observations on judicial procedure in actions criminal and civil

treatise on the law of guarantees and of principal & surety.

treatise on the law of guarantees and of principal & surety.

manual of Gothic mouldings

manual of Gothic mouldings

Victor Herbert

Victor Herbert

Leaders guide for group study of Spending time alone with God, [by] Barry St. Clair

Leaders guide for group study of Spending time alone with God, [by] Barry St. Clair

Celebrating the southern seasons

Celebrating the southern seasons

Blue Pete: detective

Blue Pete: detective

Reactive data structures for geographic information systems

Reactive data structures for geographic information systems

Cardiovascular therapeutics

Cardiovascular therapeutics

Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults. Download PDF EPUB FB2

Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults / Author: Manitoba Law Reform Commission. Publication info. In today’s In re Guardianship of Kennedy (Iowa Apr.

18, ), a mother — the legal guardian of her year-old “intellectually disabled” son — decided that her son should get a. Compulsory sterilization, also known as forced or coerced sterilization, is a term used for government-mandated programs which bring about sterilization of people.

Several countries implemented sterilization programs in the early 20th century. Although such programs have been made illegal in most countries of the world, instances of forced or coerced sterilizations persist.

Involuntary Sterilization of Mentally Retarded Minors in Nebraska Mark A. Small University of Nebraska College of Law Follow this and additional works at: This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law, College of at [email protected] of Nebraska - Lincoln.

It has been. Compulsory sterilization, also known as forced sterilization (or compulsory sterilisation respectively forced sterilisation – see spelling differences), programs are government policies which attempt to force people to undergo surgical the first half of the 20th century, several such programs were instituted in countries around the world, usually as part of.

§ Sterilization of a mentally incompetent individual or of an institutionalized individual. Programs or projects to which this subpart applies shall not perform or arrange for the performance of a sterilization of any mentally incompetent individual or institutionalized individual.

Discussion paper on sterilization of minors and mentally incompetent adults / Manitoba Law Reform Commission. KF M35 Report on sterilization and legal incompetence / Manitoba Law Reform Commission. Individuals who are legally incompetent include minors and sufficiently-disabled adults.

The discussion reached a consensus that involuntary sterilization (or sterilization with substituted consent) is only permissible if it has an explicit positive effect on the physical or mental health of the individual: this is called therapeutic sterilization.

Laws forbidding sterilization of the mentally incompetent may be nearly as dehumanizing as the forced sterilization laws they replaced. Weighing the complex medical and ethical issues involved, judging whether guardians' fears are reasonable, and determining patients' best interests require careful, individual case reviews with strict Cited by: 7.

In the landmark case of E. (Mrs.) vs. Eve (), the Supreme Court of Canada set limits on the non-therapeutic and therapeutic sterilization of mentally incapable (incompetent) patients.

1 While that case was decided more than 25 years ago, those limits still apply to medical practice today. Sterilization of Intellectually Disabled Minors (Standing Committee of Attorneys General) 5 appropriate answer.

If there is an identifiable and pressing need for parents and carers alike then surely the answer lies in carefully structured education, behaviour management and supervision.

Sterilization of Minors Validity of minors' consent "Total ban solution"" pros and cons Minnesota i 1 3 Sterilization of Racial Minorities and t~P~r 6 Reported abuse Procedural safeguards The right to procreate Minnesota Issue Sterilization of the Mentally Incompetent 8 Validity of consent Total ban solution The situation in Minnesota Eugenic.

The same conditions set forth for sterilization of legally incompetent persons under III, B, 2, above, should apply, except that the additional approval of the next of kin (or if lacking such kin, of a guardian ad litem) should be substituted for the consent of the legal guardian of the person, if there is no legal guardian other than a public.

The steps in declaring an individual as mentally incompetent are as follows: 1. File a form to declare a person as an incompetent before the Probate Court having jurisdiction over the area where the subject of the petition resides.

This form shall include an application to be declared as court appointed guardian. Canada. Sterilization was common; 12 Alberta and British Columbia enacted legislation for sterilization of the ‘mentally defective’ that remained in place till A landmark was reached in in the case of ‘Eve’, a 24 year old woman with intellectual disability, when an application made by her mother for the authorization of consent for tubal ligation was dismissed on Cited by: Law Reform Commission of Canada, 'Approaches to sterilization', Sterilization: Implications for Mentally Retarded and Mentally Ill Persons, Working Paper 24 (): -- Institute of Law Research and Reform, Edmonton, Alberta, Sterilization Decisions: Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults, Report for Discussion 6 (March ): -- "Discussion Paper on Sterilization of Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults".

English "Discussion Paper on Sterilization of Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults". "This book reveals secrets that will eliminate business-writing phobias and faux pas and help you create outstanding documents that get optimal results." B The.

Juvenile corrections. a latin term that refers to the state as guardian for minors and for people who are mentally incompetent. reform school. A penal institution to which especially young or first-time offenders are committed for training and reformation. Delinquent offenses.

Acts committed by juveniles that,if committed by adults,could. This sample paper on (Sample Research Paper on Sterilization of the Handicapped or Mentally Disabled) was uploaded by one our contributors and does not necessarily reflect how our professionals write our papers.

If you would like this paper removed from our website, please contact us our Contact Us Page. If a person is below the age of majority in their nation or locality or has been adjudged to be incompetent, editing about that person should be done with even greater care than in an ordinary biography of a living person, because in many jurisdictions, privacy and publicity rights require even greater protection than they do for competent adults.

These people typically have less. Supp. Conn. ), a Connecticut law that permitted sterilization only of mentally disabled individuals in institutions was struck down on equal protection grounds. at Some laws required sterilization as a precondition to release from state institutions.

See, e.g., Buck v. Bell, U.S. (). Moral and Ethical Issues: Guardianship, Sterilization, Involuntary Servitude, Baby Doe, and Euthanasia Since ancient times, moral and ethical issues have surrounded society‟s treatment of people with developmental disabilities. While times and circumstances have changed, many of these basic moral and ethical dilemmas have not.

Compulsory Sterilization of the Mentally III and Retarded: In re Sterilization of Moore The director of the Forsyth County Department of Social Services, pur-suant to the North Carolina compulsory sterilization statute,' filed a petition with the county district court seeking a court order for sterilization of Joseph Lee by: 1.

Should violent sex offenders be ordered to undergo sterilization. Should women who receive Medicaid and continue to have unknown fathers be required to be sterilized. Should mentally incompetent women be sterilized. Are children treated as property. Sterilizing Minors and Incompetents: The sterilization of legal and mental incompetents is a legally risky endeavor because of a strong societal policy against forcing or coercing individuals to be sterilized.

If a medical care practitioner or other person uses the threat of withdrawal of federally funded services to coerce a person into.

to patients who are minors or medically incompetent. Definitions: 1. Medically Incompetent- a medically incompetent person is one who is not competent to give informed consent because of age, immaturity, mental impairment or medical condition.

Medical incompetence renders one incompetent to consent to or to refuse medical care. Compulsory sterilization programs are government policies which attempt to force people to undergo surgical sterilization. Individuals who are legally incompetent include minors and sufficiently-disabled adults.

Discussion Paper on Sterilization of Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults. Winnipeg: medical treatment were not considered. In this paper we explore the idea of a similar legal I Mentally Incapacitated Adults and Decision-Making: An Overview (), Consultation Paper No.

Mentally Disabled Adults: Legal Arrangements for Managing their Welfare and Finances (), Discussion Paper No. File Size: 6MB. Compulsory sterilization (or sterilisation) Information about the California sterilization program was produced into book form and widely disseminated by eugenicists E.S.

Gosney and Paul B. Popenoe, Discussion Paper on Sterilization of Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults. Winnipeg: While involuntary sterilization is no longer legal, surgical steril- ization is still presented as a viable option to minors and adult women with developmental disabilities and is legally.

Law Reform Commission, Sterilization: Implications for Mentally Retarded and Mentally Ill Persons, Working Paper 24 (), Institute of Law Research and Reform, Edmonton, Alberta, Sterilization Decisions: Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults, Report for Discussion No.

6 (March ), Brand: Routledge. STERILIZATION OF MINORS AND THE DISABLED (SEVERAL STATUTES) C.R.S. § Sterilization rights. (1) It is the intent of the general assembly that the procedures set forth in the following subsections be utilized when sterilization is being considered for the primary purpose of rendering the individual incapable of reproduction.

The Act changes the standard of proof for order regarding sterilization of mentally incompetent persons from a preponderance of evidence to clear and convincing evidence.

It provides for closed hearings and trials in connection with sterilization orders, the addition of a psychiatrist or psychologist on the examining team to determine whether a person is mentally incompetent.

Though a full discussion of sterilization's legal and ethical implications is beyond the scope of this paper, it is important to recognize the long history of compulsory and involuntary Author: Douglas Diekema. The moral standing of involuntary sterilization has long been subject to debate but has only recently been looked upon with disfavor.

When sterilization of a mentally handicapped minor is entertained, issues of eugenics, medical ethics, and legal precedent specially by: 3. Sample Annotated Bibliography Paper on Sterilization of the Handicapped or Mentally Disabled We do not share your personal information with any company or person.

We have also ensured that the ordering process is secure; you can check the security feature in the browser. Who Should Make Medical Decisions for Incompetent Adults. A Critique of RCW Adrienne E. Quinn* I. INTRODUCTION Advances in medical technology give us a better chance of surviving a serious accident or illness than ever before.

On a daily basis, heart attack victims, accident victims, and cancer patients are. For a helpful discussion of the New Jersey Supreme Court decision, see Ottobre, Notes - Incompetents - Sterilization, 12 SETON HALL, LAW REV.

96 (). BERNARD M. DICKENS re Quinlan, where it held that a mentally incompetent woman's right to terminate mechanical means of life-support was a "valuable incident of her right to privacyCited by: 3. Empirical Analysis of Sterilization of Mentally Handicapped Individuals in the United States ).

This paper will include both children and adults in the category of mental handicap. Sterilization For the purposes of this paper, sterilization refers to the surgical methods of contraception such as tubal ligation, hysterectomy or vasectomy. In its enactment of sectionsubdivision (d), and the omission of any provision in other legislation authorizing sterilization of incompetent developmentally disabled persons, the Legislature has denied incompetent women the procreative choice that is recognized as a fundamental, constitutionally protected right of all other adult women.

Law Reform Commission, Sterilization: Implications for Mentally Retarded and Mentally Ill Persons, Working Paper 24 (), 23– Institute of Law Research and Reform, Edmonton, Alberta, Sterilization Decisions: Minors and Mentally Incompetent Adults, Report for Discussion No. 6 (March ), 41– Mental abuse is a lot harder to define, there has to be several physicians who deem a child has been mentally abused.

Sexual abuse would be any individual inappropriately touching a child. One can birth a child who is born with a substance addiction, this would also be considered a crime against a child.ARTICLE 1. Workers' Compensation Act.

Section § Limitation as against minors or mentally incompetent. No limitation of time provided in this Article for the giving of notice or making claim under this Article shall run against any person who is mentally incompetent, or a minor dependent, as long as he has no guardian, trustee, or committee.